Let It Blurt The Life and Times of Lester Bangs, America’s Greatest Rock Critic |
||
A Sampling of Email from Readers
|
||
From:
"Robert A. Farace, Jr." <rfarace@uconect.net To: <jimdero@earthlink.net
Sent: Monday, April 03, 2000 9:39 PM Subject: the new book Hi, Just thought I'd say that I've been looking forward to reading the book on Lester Bangs as soon as I found out about it. For the longest time I considered Psychotic Reactions and Carburetor Dung to be the only book on rock worth reading, and although I've modified my opinion a little in the ensuing years, it's still the best. I had a habit for a while of picking up used copies whenever I saw them so I could give them to cool people that would appreciate it. Would have been neat if you could have included a flexi disk of "Let it Blurt" with the book; I have it on an unlabelled tape somewhere, among many other unlabelled tapes, and I'd love to hear it again. Thanks also for pointing out what should have been obvious to me, that Bangs's writing was firmly in the Beat tradition. I've long held that his writing was just as rock and roll as what he was writing about, but I never saw the parallel. I guess Bangs hopped up on Romilar writing about rock is not much different than Kerouac hopped up on speed writing about bop. There's a guy that owns a used record store in the area (Replay Records, West Haven, CT) that played behind Lester one night, I think he said in the basement of the Village Gate. Quine was on guitar; I forget who else he said played. He didn't know about the book, so I told him. Anyway, looking forward to a good read. I'm sure the book will meet with an appreciative audience. -- Bob Farace * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: "Steven Ward" <sward@theadvocate.com To: <jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: Monday, April 10, 2000 10:18 AM Subject: Throat Culture Hi Jim, Steven Ward here. I'm the guy that did the Paul Nelson interview for rockcritics.com. I just finished your Bangs bio. It was wonderful. One of the best rock bios or writer bios I have ever read. Good job. Later, Steven Ward * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: "AARON COHEN" <aaron.cohen@morningstar.com To: <jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: Wednesday, April 19, 2000 2:04 PM Subject: Let It Blurt Made My Weekend! Hi, Jim: I just wanted to drop a quick note saying that I was completely engrossed in "Let It Blurt" and only slept a little between the time I opened it and when I finished the tome. Last time that happened to me over the course of a weekend was the fall of '87 when "Psychotic Reactions" was published, and it helped push me along a path that I have continued to follow. Amazing the amount of research that you did in working with Bangs' family, delving into the history of the Jehovah's Witnesses, among all the other assorted interviews and reading that packed the pages. My favorite parts, though, were when Lester and Paul Nelson sat on the rooftop during the '77 blackout watching the Bronx fires, and when Lester asked Bob Marley if he ever used his gold BMW to ram a goat. Before I read it, my friend Monica Kendrick warned me that "How To Be A Rock Critic" would hit way close to home, and she was right. Since I was reviewing the Curtis Mayfield Memorial Tribute for the Tribune, I couldn't attend the Empty Bottle book release party/gig. It's cool, though, that both events that night were benefits for Cabrini Green causes. I'll keep on listening to your show. It's my favorite program on Chicago radio. --Aaron * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subj: congrats Date: 4/19/00 11:20:46 PM Central Daylight Time From: Rwnedelkof To: JimDeRo Dear Jim: Don't know if you'll recall that we met years ago at the New Music Seminar, or maybe South by Southwest, or both, but I wanted to congratulate you about <ILet It Blurt. </IThe research is staggering and the data far better integrated than is the case with some writers with a dozen bios under their belt. A more detailed email about my impressions of the book will be sent later. I do want to say that, given Doubleday's usual keenness to issue audiobooks, I'm surprised to find, via amazon or elsewhere, that there seem to be no plans for an audio version of this one, using all the tapes. People like myself, who have a couple of hours of Lester on tape (from Phil Milstein's collection in my case) and who've met Tosches and Meltzer, have small difficulty conjuring up in our heads the uproarious words of the Buffalo seminar that you transcribe. But younger, less worldly readers - or ones in Estonia or someplace- might well need some help. Again, congratulations. Sinc, Robert Nedelkoff * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subject: 'Let it Blurt' Date: Sat, 22 Apr 2000 14:05:08 -0500 From: "Douglas E. Webber" <DWebber@CIL.KnowledgeONE.net To: "'JIMDERO@earthlink.net'" <JIMDERO@earthlink.net Dear Jim, From the moment I read in 'Perfect Sound Forever' (online zine) about this book, I knew I had to get it. Well, I bought it yesterday evening and finished it around midnight. What a great job you've done. As a teen in suburban Philadelphia in the early 70's, I knew radio sucked. Bangs showed me the way to great stuff like the Dolls, Ramones, Velvets, Voidoids, etc. It would really be a treat to have him around today. This book is a remarkably balanced look at a true original. I am so happy Bangs' story was in your capable hands. Best wishes, Douglas Webber * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subject: Let It Blurt Date: Sat, 22 Apr 2000 16:46:13 -0400 From: "Joe Hedio" <joehedio@prodigy.net Organization: Prodigy Internet To: <jimdero@earthlink.net Dear Jim: I just finished reading Let It Blurt today & I just want to say that I liked it a lot. I always feel that a hallmark of a good biography is that you learn about other people besides the subject & it was certainly true of your book in that I learned about the people around Lester professionally & personally. I also got the strong impression that his upbriging, especially his father's death & his family's reaction to it had a profound & determental effect on Lester. I liked reading his article on how to be a rock critic. To me, he ranks right up there w/H.L. Mencken and P.G. Wodehouse as writers that I enjoy reading their works. Admittedly, I really only got into Lester through Carborator Dung, but it was good & left me hungry for more. I like to see more of his writings to be available. Again, you did a good job & have a Happy Easter to you & yours. Sincerely, Joe Hedio P.S.: I also liked your 1st book * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subj: Blurt! Date: 4/24/00 8:54:39 PM Central Daylight Time From: kurage@adelphia.net (hernon) To: JimDeRo@aol.com Just finished plowing through my copy of "Blurt!" and a tip of the bottle to you my man. A wonderful job deserving of more praise than I am capable of pouring out. It hit home fairly hard my friend, especially the formative days at Creem and such. This writing about rock and roll gig can be a real bitch at times. I can also be one helluva hoot, but mostly it seems to bring about fits of depression - and I don't even do it professionally. I'm not so sure I would want to. My few forays into the world of "proper" rock journalism have been extraordinary downers. I guess the whole scene is one of profession not passion these days, and the writing fucking shows it. I mean, I love music man...I fucking love rock and roll and it has kept my motor running through some awful times in life (as well as some great ones too) but the "profession" you inhabit has become either dull and careerist or quite simply mawkish. You, my friend (and I do realize that you don't know me from Adam, but I consider you a friend on principle alone) seem to understand all of this and I am not sure why I am draining this all on your driveway, but it eats away at me quite often nowadays. I know that there are not a lot of folks who want what I may have to offer, people just don't seem that interested in open communications about music and culture anymore, and I am certain that many people would consider my work as amateurish ("too self-indulgent" one editor of an arty local weekly called some of my work - I told him "of course it is...isn't rock and roll itself? That's what I'm writing about damn it" - and he still offered me a gig) or maybe boring (that would hurt), but they don't understand - I HAVE TO DO IT. I HAVE to write about music, I am compelled, maybe even possessed, whatever you want to call it. I call it a curse (when I'm down about it all) or just flat out fun (when I love it). Maybe I do it on a very small scale, but that really doesn't matter in the long haul. Not to me at least. I feel I am part of something much bigger than my scribbles. What exactly that is I may never know. Reading Lester, and reading about Lester brings me to that place where I have to realize that this is a passion play - whether any of us like it or not. Lester had that passion, that fire, more than anyone else I've ever read. He represented the highs and lows of art charting the same highs and the same lows of life itself. It's a sack of lies and life is a hypocrites game, the heart you wear on your sleeve better be a phony one because it's gonna get bloodied daily. So here I am, gasping after nearly drowning myself in your fine tome. I am caught in a place where my instincts say keep on keepin' on and my mind keeps playing the old trick of fooling me into wanting to expand myself. Maybe even, gulp, turn pro. But the pro's probably wouldn't want me anyway, I try to be my own man and speak my own voice - whether that thing I call "style" would be other peoples "shit" I do not know. For now my web writings will continue and, hopefully, will honor the aethetic of personal art. Because ultimately art is personal, it's just that more than a few of us feel the need to blurt about it every now and then. Thanks for the ear Jim, I appreciate you taking the time. These things are in my head constantly and the need to shake it up and pop the top comes along every now and again. You just happened to be the poor fellow standing next to me. Kurt Hernon p.s. your kind words about my Lester tribute in Perfect Sound Forver were unexpected and welcomed. I thank you again for giving a "little" guy a quick read. I won't stop, I can't stop, even if the bangSheet Online remains my only fortress...I'll buy you a beer sometime friend. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Date: 4/25/00 8:25:57 PM Central Daylight Time From: Chineserocks77 To: JimDeRo Sent on: AOL 4.0 for Windows 95 hey i just finished reading let it blurt and i think its brilliant and captivating... i didn't think it could top my favorite book 'kelidoscope eyes' but it has... you did a great job digging up all this information about lester, im in shock, of how good it was. i was just reading the newest issue of 'entertainment weekly' (which you have probably read) and they say that the final chapters of your book are as riveting as Scorsese's Goodfellas, which i think is very true. so what i was wondering is if you would ever turn 'let it blurt' and if you did would you have Scorsese direct it... who do you think should play lester? i want to! sorry if this isn't a very professional letter, im only 18 and i get high all of the time and read your books, keuorac, lenny bruce and eric bogosian... please write me back and tell me what you think God ( i mean jim) peace out chief, steve * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: Alex Torralbas To: DeRogatis Jim Sent: Tuesday, April 25, 2000 10:02 AM Subject: Blurt - thanks from someone who knew him I just read "Let it Blurt" and thank you for doing Lester's memory proud. I spent the summer of '77 in New York and looked him up in the phone book and rang him up. He was more than a great writer: he was my "hero", too. Over that summer he let me hang out with him at his apartment, took me boozing at the Bells of Hell, even had me come along with Christ Stein, Debbie Harry, and himself, riding out to Coney Island for the Punk Mutant Monster Beach party shoot in this big name photog's car (can't remember his name right now). It pissed down with rain and I hung out under the Boardwalk falling for Lauren Agnelli (who wouldn't remember me any more than the cold she had that summer). Afterwards we all went to Punk's offices and all I remember was pretty much everyone getting very fucked up, and then me and Legs McNeil and Holmstrom and a bunch of us going for Chinese food. Lester and I traded letters for years, starting in about 73, when he was at Creem. I gave him some tapes of music I was writing and one song got swiped and wound up on the Birdland album (track 1 side 1). I only found this out way after his death and I didn't feel bad: it was such an honor (stupidly) that Lester would like something of mine enough to swipe it. His lyrics, 95% my music. I read some more of your stuff on your site and really enjoyed it. The thing on the R&R Hall of Fame is perfect. By the way, the line about choosing between depression or anxiety was an old Lester mantra. He told it to me the day I met him in July of 77. I reread a bunch of my writings from the time and even before and can so much understand the corner he was in - roughly, if rock n roll is more than just some noise I listen to, and rock n roll is dead or dying, and even though I should know better that there's no way to stuff LIFE into this thing called rock n roll, then what the fuck do I do now? You gotta be there to know how that feels. You did a damn fine job of allowing others, my wife, for instance, to understand why Lester meant so much to those of us who knew him, if only fleetingly. Regards, Alex Torralbas (aka The Subliminal Kid) * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subj: Let It Blurt! Date: 4/26/00 9:07:11 PM Central Daylight Time From: sugarspin@hotmail.com (KV- sugarspin) To: jimdero@aol.com Hey Jim, I don't know if you remember me, but I'm the female musician from Arkansas who asked you to sign a copy of your book at the Empty Bottle show. I finished reading it and thought I would let you know that I really enjoyed it. It was inspiring coming from the artist side of me, but yet once again confirmed the aggravations that I have with the social and business aspects of music. We could have debates about that all day, couldn't we? I just want you to know that I started a list of CDs that I have to have after reading the book, too. I went to CDNOW.com and listened to Lester's first album and actually kind of liked it. The Jook Savage album was out of stock but that one really peaks my interest. Anyway, enjoyed the book! Thanks, KV * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: "Adam Blake" <adamblake77@hotmail.com> To: jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: April 27, 2000 11:55:42 PM GMT Subject: salutations from limeyland Dear Jim deRogatis, I cannot tell you how much I enjoyed "Let It Blurt". Having long given up reading music mags or papers I had no idea of its existence till I wandered in to my local book shop and there it was. I bought it immediately and devoured it within 48 hours. Thank you. You did it right. It must have been a very hard book to write. I never met Lester but I know people who did and I know his work and I think you did as good a job as anybody could have done. The fact that it exists means it will, inevitably, become easier for people like me to explain why their favourite American writer is someone with a ludicrous name that hardly anybody has heard of who wrote almost exclusively about rock 'n' roll. I love the quotation from Oscar Wilde's "The Critic As Artist". Apposite, you might say. Wilde is another of my favourite writers and, funnily enough, someone with whom I feel Lester had a lot in common: both big and overbearing men, obsessive, formidable raconteurs, with a terrifying self-destructiveness that must have been heartbreaking for those who loved them. And yes, of course, the gift of being able to inspire others. One thing: you attempt an overview of the birth (and death) of rock criticism. A laudable aim and I think you succeed but why did you not mention Nik Cohn's book "Awopbopaloobop Alopbamboom" which was published under the title "Pop From The Beginning" in 1969. This may not have influenced Lester per se but it was, nonetheless, the first rock'n'roll book that attempted to put the music in perspective within its own terms. It still stands up today - or at least the parts of it that deal with 50s rock'n'roll do - I'm sure you've read it. Perhaps you felt an English book was irrelevent to what you were writing about but I'd be curious to know why you didn't make mention of it. The appendices were wonderful. I'd not read them before and after such a sad ending it was a joy to hear Lester's voice in such fine fettle. The list of his work was so tantalising. It's tough to know there is so much of his work that I have not read. I collect what pieces I can find in old books, magazines and on the internet but there is still so much I can't get hold of. Do you think there is any chance that there will be another volume of his work? As time goes by, it becomes clearer and clearer that he really was the best writer rock'n'roll ever had. Isn't that justification enough? I thought you could have quoted a bit from Nick Kent's obituary ("Ballad of a Loudhearted Man") which was a beautiful bit of writing from perhaps Lester's most talented imitator. Never mind. I never liked Marcus's writing except when he wrote the foreword to Lester's book. Strange isn't it. I truly think that Lester had a sublime gift: in his own work and in his ability to inspire others. I think I'm beginning to repeat myself so I'll sign off now. Hope you don't mind me drivelling on. Thank you again. All the best. Adam Blake * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * X-Da-secret-hail-everybody: we [heart] Evan Davies <me@evandavies.com>, bigtime!!!! by way of the Bomp list, so apologies to the couple of you who will see it twice. okay...the Bangs' book, er, review...right, so all you bomplisters allow me to preface my words with a few more words...my editress says I can't bust 300 words, and this is tailored for print publication...which is not marketed to those "in the know"...as for the "readability"...I know how it looks and may be hard to read, "derivative", but its what I do, honest, its how I've always done it...that is when I can get scratch for a bit of scritch, you know, like "published"...I promise not to post such drivel unless requested (as Mr. Apollo did, thank you sir)...now then... Let It Blurt: The Life & Times of Lester Bangs, America's Greatest Rock Critic Honestly, y'all...how long we been needin' a biography on thee "gonzo" rock critic...WRITER, that is the late Lester Bangs? Welp, we got one now, called "Let It Blurt"...and, the way I figger, this is ONE which cain't, won't, be beat! Fer ONCE sumpthin' got done right...the first time! Mister DeRogatis, thank you, you done did a damn fine job...if it was up to ME, I'd give you a raise! I'm serious! In terms of "good" writin' "Blurt" is well done, most folks who take license to write about "rock" often have their heads up their you-know-whats (read: ASSES), but this is heads 'n' shoulders above the other flakes. Straight away the pacing and dynamics were sharply defined and it kept clippin' along with no draggin', overwritten or sleepy-time underdetailed bits! Now, in addition to smart writin', you rock 'n' rolla GEEKoids, sorry..."hobbyists", take note 'cause if you like "pictures", there's loads of exclusive illustrations, er...pictures, plus there's tons of contextual history, like stories of Bangs' incarceration at Campus de la Creem and all those involved..., even if this WON'T about Bangs, the fleshy, fatty details of the peripheral characters and events warrant a read (Jimmy I think there IS another book here)! But, above of all, I was struck by the thoughtful presentation of the relationship Bangs' had to his scritchin'...that is, this book testifies that Bangs' writin' is an explicit expression of HIS personality through a desperate, deliberate reach for an articulation of feeling! Duh. And, Jimmy, many more thanks fer NOT imposin' no writer's "editorial" hogwash on Lester's less than stable life. Yeah, Lester was a wee bit fucked in the noodle..., but YOU, dear readers, will haveta read the book yerselves to find out WHY. M'kay? Now then, go get it!!! * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: "Andy Fuertsch" <andropolis@prodigy.net To: jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: May 2, 2000 1:53:20 AM GMT Subject: Great work Dear Jim, I got through your book "Let it Blurt" this weekend and I must say it is excellent. I got to know Lester better through your book. So good in fact I'm going to have to read it again. The stories came out at me and I could picture all those scenes happening in Detroit and New York. I knew something about the times that he lived in New York but you set it all straight and gave Lester a great soul that probably few people thought he had. Lester was a true infamous character and in parts of the book it made me laugh out loud. The Lester I knew when we all collaborated with him and the music in the Delinquents. He was only down in Austin for a short time and the chapter on that episode brought back memories and it rings fast and true. His life went by too quick. Great work, ---Andy Fuertsch * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: "Jeanne Bredestege" <timejeanneb@earthlink.net To: jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: May 2, 2000 5:24:52 AM GMT Subject: FW: Tim Ellison, Let It Blurt reader Dear Jim, Thank you so much for your Lester Bangs book. Lester means so much to me and your book is beautifully done and an enormous achievement. I was excited when I first read (in a Robot Hull interview from about a year and a half ago) that it was forthcoming, but must admit that I had some reservations about it when I got wind of it coming out recently. I was worried about the possibilities of it dwelling on sordidness. I am so happy that the picture of Lester's life documented in your extraordinary book has such an emphasis on Lester's tough, critical inner dialogue, his insights on truth, and his desire for growth. I am a believer in the accuracy of this portrayal, particularly in light of the dismissive tone of Meltzer and Tosches' writing about Lester. That your book can ring true over both Meltzer and Tosches on one hand (I'm referring particularly to Meltzer's 'Recollected in Tranquility' and the Meltzer/Tosches dialogue in Throat Culture), and Christgau and Marcus on the other is a real triumph for Lester. And for you. Two points on your Afterword. Who are the rock critics that are imitative of Lester but aren't any good that you refer to? If you're referring to Chuck Eddy/Frank Kogan/et al, I'd agree that their ironicist style has little to do with Lester's aesthetic interests. If, however, you are referring (as I am afraid you might be) to punk writers from the later eighties and nineties who have made some impacts (Byron Coley, Chris Stigliano, Jay Hinman, etc.), I'd say you were being frighteningly dismissive and I would wonder why. My second point on the Afterword is that I think Lester would blanch at the idea of extending his "La Bamba" through "Blitzkrieg Bop" lineage to Nirvana! The crucial component for Lester was "gets more primitive each time," which I would argue does not occur in the transference from The Ramones to Nirvana. The transition from The Ramones to, say, The Gories (one example--early '90's Detroit band with three LPs) is an actual progression along these lines! Regards, Tim Ellison * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Date: 5/4/00 10:51:51 PM Central Daylight Time From: jon@webley.com (Jon Wotman) To: JimDeRo@aol.com hey jim: made my way through LET IT BLURT, and was suitably impressed. everyone's a critic, and i'm sure people wanted different things from the book. personally, i would have liked 20 pages on the composition of "Peter Laughner," but you chose not to get too graphic about the construction of any of Lester's articles. prolly a good choice, since most of the time such biographical efforts are an exercise in hero construction, and have nothing to do with the lonely process of assembling words that people might read. the worst part of the book is your immaculate and very thorough bibliography... it highlights exactly how much we're all missing. thanks, jw * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: "craig ablah" <hcraig@feist.com To: jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: May 5, 2000 6:15:49 PM GMT Subject: let it blurt Jim: Just wanted to drop you a short note to let you know how much I liked Let it Blurt. It must have been fascinating research for you. What's so cool about Lester is how he made the transition so seamless between the hippie 60s and punk 70s - and was true to himself throughout ( I can't think of any other figure that was so prominent in both movements). That last appendix you included was very revealing and tied up the book nicely. The timing was perfect - I've been buying those old bound volumes of Rolling Stone on ebay recently, so I'd been reading much of his early work. You really put his writing in perspective for me. Thanks for a great book - I thoroughly enjoyed it. Best Regards, Craig Ablah Wichita KS * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subj: Re: Lester Bangs Date: 5/5/00 3:22:28 AM Central Daylight Time From: discojen@hotmail.com (Jenny Kiely) To: JimDeRo@aol.com Hi Jim I wrote to you last year regarding your book about Lester Bangs - you probably don't remember, as it was ages ago! Well, it's finally out here in England, and I bought it for my boyfriend Jim, as promised. All I can tell you is that he can't put the book down - I'll be chatting away to him about stuff, and he's like, 'Hmm??'- no response. I can only assume it is a great book from this! I can't wait until he finishes it, and then we can have a conversation, then I can read it!! Seriously, I'm so pleased for you that the book finally came out. We need to know about people like Lester Bangs. Have you seen any of the press stuff in the English papers? We kept a piece from The Observer, so let me know if you want a copy of it. Anyway, thanks. Jen xxx * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subj: Lester Date: 5/6/00 2:30:03 PM Central Daylight Time From: mathitak@sirius.com (Mark Athitakis) To: jimdero@aol.com I just finished "Let it Blurt" -- really, about five minutes ago -- and I just wanted to shoot a message to say how much I enjoyed it. I recall your contention about the use of the word "hagiography" in the interview we did a couple of years back. It certainly isn't that -- it reads like the honest assessment the man deserved, and frankly makes a lot of the choices in Carburetor Dung seem skewed. It was a pleasure to read, and I'm glad somebody did it. I notice only one small nit to pick, or at least question: I wonder if Nancy Alexander's grandmother's real name is "Yi-Ya," as the passage on her sugget. Because I come from a Greek family, I always referred to my grandmothers as "Yia-Yia" -- it's a term of affection, but not their real names, Phaedra and Maria. I know, a screamingly minor point. Best, mark. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: gretschbikini58 To: jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: May 6, 2000 2:23:45 AM GMT Subject: buffalo gals
Sucker that I am I spent the last of my welfare cheque on Lester Bangs. I wound up carrying him home from the bookstore where I found him lying on a shelf.... He's been great company. The book's fantastic. I'm too young and I live on the wrong side of the Atlantic to have come across Lester whilst still alive but after reading "Psychotic Reactions" I appreciated him for his consistency of vision (unlike the Lou Reeds and the Iggy Pops of this world). Is the US book cover different to the UK? Thanks for writing the book and good luck Thor PS About 8 years ago my old group recorded a version of Roky Erickson's "You're Gonna Miss Me" we were called Carburetor Dung. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Hi Jim Like many people (I'm guessing) who've read your book, I, too, had a personal relationship with Lester that found a tender revival in its pages...Lester, in a way, was like a father figure to me. I grew up in the "Creem" house, both in Birmingham and on the farm in Walled Lake, and there were many times when Lester took me under his wing and corrupted me, no doubt in his own mind in proper peripatetic fashion, with the knowledge and experience befitting a nine year-old kid who just happend to love Lou Reed as much as his Romilar driven Aristotle...My reward? My rite of passage? My proverbial "15" minutes outside of the many sundry C.C. Rider supermarket escapades with Lester -- ('Here Josh, take this bologna, here's some bread, get me that mustard over there, open up those cookies, fun eh?', etc., etc.) -- well, he published me in CREEM at the ripe-old-age of 10, in a review of "Rock-N-Roll Animal" no less, which then gave vent to the closing five minutes of those fifteen when Lou Reed himself responded to Lester's gesture by asking him where the 'little asshole was' who reviewed his album. Ah, well, Jim, thanks for helping to rekindle those memories, and more importantly, for providing and preserving a clear portrait of Lester beyond myth or romance... Thanks, again. Josh Bassett * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
I am an Italian reader who is going through your
brilliant Lester Bangs book. Is there any chance that you will put together a follow
up to the LB collected works of Psychotic Reaction? Take care. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: "fxxm" <fxxm@aspma.com> * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subj: Re: Hey Bob Of course, it was obvious from his writing, but I was
still impressed
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subj: Let It Blurt. One more thing-I heard you mention on sound opinions
something about the Univ. of Chicago Press Archives containing vintage rock criticism-is
this true? Would love to hear more about this-I'm a collector of
the printed word as it pertains to pop music.Anyway-great book,and a great job at the
Suntimes.Cool radio show too. Sincerely, Jim Weihsmantel. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Dear Jim: I just finished reading Let It Blurt today &
I just want to say that I liked it a lot. I always feel that a hallmark of a good
biography is that you learn about other people besides the subject & it was
Joe Hedio
Subject: Thanx for 'Let It Blurt' Date: Sat, 03 Jun 2000 22:51:15 +1000 From: radiocitizen <dcitizen@austasia.net> To: Jim DeRogatis <jimdero@earthlink.net>
Hello Mr. DeRogatis I am writing to praise your recent book about Lester Bangs. I bought it yesterday and have almost finished it - so far I have thoroughly enjoyed it... Lester was responsible for introducing me to a lot of the music that I still love to this day. I first read him in the pages of Creem in 1974 when I was a clueless 13-year-old growing up near Melbourne, Australia. Even though at that time I knew next to nothing about most of the musicians he championed - and nothing about Lester himself - I was immediately attracted to the obvious sincerity, humour and passion evident in his writing. As a result I bought many of the albums he recommended and was almost never disappointed in what I heard as a result ('Horses', Brian Eno, Pharoah Sanders, Miles Davis, and The Velvet Underground, amongst others). It got to the point where I could tell what he would think of a particular record before I even read his review of it - and I almost always agreed with him. I remember buying Lou Reed's 'The Bells' and immediately falling in love with it and trying to convince my friends of what a great piece of work it is - but they all rubbished it mercilessly. The only contrary opinion I found - and the only one that ended up counting to me - was Lester's beautiful review in Rolling Stone. What he wrote about 'The Bells' almost made me cry. Even though I never knew him personally, it was one of the saddest days in my life when I heard he was dead. Thankyou for writing a great biography of a great, great writer and music-lover. More power to you. sincerely Dario Cittadini
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Bangs book and such Date: 6/5/00 5:55:00 PM Central Daylight Time From: RandyF2930 To: JimDeRo Sent on: AOL 5.0 for Windows Jim, I wanted to thank you for your work on the Lester Bangs bio. I was looking forward to its release and was in no way disappointed after reading it. I honestly had trouble putting it down. As a 36 year old, who began working in record stores at the age of 15, well, I grew up reading Lester in Creem and his other various outlets. His essay on Astral Weeks from Stranded was and is simply one of the greatest things I've ever read. It's funny, I probably started buying Creem when I was about 10 years old, and Lester's style and passion hit me right from the git-go. Also, noticed on the jacket that you've written for World of Wrestling. It's damn hard to find music writers who appreciate decent pro wrestling. Anyhow, you did a wonderful job on the book. Buy the way, do you know what Robert Quine is doing these days? Take care, randy fox
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: LESTER STRIKES BACK! Date: 6/5/00 1:27:31 PM Central Daylight Time From: dleifer@kramerlevin.com To: JIMDERO@aol.com
Jim: Thanks for getting back to me so quickly. As I mentioned, I wrote the letter the day I saw the article on the RS online edition, but it took me a while to track down an e-mail address for you. In addition to Rolling Stone (who will definitely NOT publish it), I also sent copies of the letter to Chuck Eddy, Carol Cooper, Ann Powers, Eric Weisbard, Doug Simmons, Vince Aletti, Addicted to Noise and E-Pulse. Eddy is the only one who bothered to answer me (other than yourself). >> Nicely done. Though really, it sort of gives AD what he wants: He hasn't had this many people read (and certainly not think) about any of his uninspired hack prose for years, if ever. And of course there was a blatant conflict for him, as an unrepentant never-tiring Jann Wenner suck-up (his screed told me what Wenner thinks of the book, if nothing else). << After reading "Let It Blurt" (actually I'm about halfway through it and am really enjoying it) I can certainly understand why Jann Wenner wanted to take a swipe at you and Lester. The book paints a rather unflattering portrait of him, but one which has been confirmed by numerous other sources. I LOVED the story of Buddy Miles storming the RS offices and Wenner escaping out the fire escape! Classic! He reminds me of Lorne Michaels, another child of the 60's who started out in the counterculture and quickly sold out as soon as the opportunity presented itself. Of course, I've never heard any stories about Lorne being a chickenhawk! HAH! It seems from your book that any talented, principled writers didn't last long at RS, where Wenner's obvious goal was to please his advertisers and the industry powers that be and to rock the boat as little as possible. What a dick! And DeCurtis's outburst was so out of proportion to the tone of your book and so out of step with the general critical opinion of Lester's writing that it seems obvious that it was an attempted assassination based on an old grudge. The fact that they only published it online is further proof of their cowardice. You and I have a similar background. I grduated from high school a year before you and also grew up in the suburbs of NYC - Westchester Co. While a senior in high school I also did a music-related independent study project - I worked as an intern for Stiff Records in NY. I even got to meet Lee Perry, the Stranglers, John Tiven and The Feelies, and got to see The Plasmatics chainsaw a TV in half on the old Tom Snyder show. Those were the days! Lester was also one of my heroes, and your book does his legacy proud. Thanks. I even turned up my copy of that old issue of Throat Culture up in my mom's attic! Thanks again for getting back to me and for the wonderful celebration of Lester. Peace, David Leifer
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Re: wnur documentary From: l-trudeau@nwu.edu (Lisa Trudeau) To: JimDeRo@aol.com At 11:05 AM 5/10/00 -0400, you wrote:
Actually, I'm a big fan of Bangs, too, and if I wasn't the poor college student that I am I would have bought your book already. (Not that I'm trying to kiss ass or anything) I have Psychotic Reactions and Carburetor Dung and his reviews are better than anything being written in music journalism today (no offense). I love his writing for the same reason I love Hunter Thompson's -- they write about what's *really* there. Just like anyone at the Kentucky Derby really goes to get loaded, people listen to rock not because of the technical prowess of the musicians, but because of what it does to them when they listen to it. Bangs understood that. Most critics are just people with opinions who get published, but Lester Bangs was a rock star himself and his writing was just as important as the music it was about. And not that you don't obviously know all of this already, but that's why I love Bangs. I definitely see how Kerouac was a huge influence on his writing -- I think Bangs has some of the same rhythm as JK. There's also a sense of the whole first-thought-best-thought thing. It's all one big expunging of thought without any sort of pretention whatsoever. As a "budding" music journalist myself, I really respectthat and try to do that in my own writing. I've learned more from people like Kerouac, Bangs and Thompson than my clueless newswriting professors in Medill. It's all about form and streamlining your writing so much that it's exactly like everyone else's and that's not what I want to do. But I'm preaching to the choir ... --lisa. "The only people for me are the mad ones, the ones who are mad to live,mad to talk, mad to be saved, desirous of everything at the same time, the ones who never yawn or say a commonplace thing, but burn, burn, burn like fabulous yellow roman candles exploding like spiders across the stars ..." --Jack Kerouac Lisa Trudeau Northwestern University, Medill School of Journalism '02
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: Let It Blurt!! Date: Wed, 7 Jun 2000 09:32:26 EDT From: Weett002@aol.com To: jimdero@earthlink.net
Just wanted to say I loved your book on Lester -- I was moved and impressed -- your research, placing him and the era in context, the descriptions of him and his relationships with colleagues, loved ones were great -- it was one of those books I ran right thru -- the sense of the loss of him -- the sense of his contributions -- Thank you!! I'll look forward to anything else you write on the topic of rock writers and I already have your book on psychedelic music yet to read!!
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: loved the book Date: 6/8/00 3:56:32 PM Central Daylight Time From: jmcgaw@ids.net (Jim McGaw) Reply-to: jmcgaw@ids.net To: jimdero@aol.com
Hi Jim, Just wanted to drop a line and let you know how much I loved your book on Lester Bangs. Man, we need him now more than ever. I know you were critical of some of the selections made by Greil Marcus in the Bangs' anthology. This begs the obvious question: Why don't you edit a sequel? I'm the same age as you, but I become hip to Lester only a few years ago. Thus, most of the stuff I've read by him is in "Psychotic Reactions." I need more! Is there any Web site that has more of his writing? I don't think I'll be shelling out $30 for back issues of Creem. Again, wonderful job. Your book inspired me to buy some Iggy and another copy of "Trout Mask Replica." I say "another" because I traded my first copy in a couple years ago. Damn thing gave me a migraine. I have new ears now so I'm sure it will sound different this time (either that or I'll enjoy the migraine. From one wanna-be critic to the real thing, Jim McGaw Portsmouth, RI
Anyway, hi how are ya loved the Lester book. I'm seventeen and I recently discovered that I'm going to be a rock critic. I know this because 1) My two biggest passions are writing and music, 2) I'm opinionated and like to tell people these opinions, regardless of their polite pleas for me to stop, and 3) I look like a rock critic. It's true. People tell me this. So with
this accessible Internet thing and you, a rock critic who writes I know
some of those questions sounded like career-oriented bullshit but that's the way the world
is, I've heard. I would greatly appreciate if you could answer these questions. Christ, I
have to wake up at 8. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From:
"John Stewart" * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subj: music
and junk Regards, Subj: For
Third Eye Blind, "Let it Blurt," and most important, keeping it real! Subj: it's all YOUR fault * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subject: A plug for you Subj: Let it Blurt
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * From: RSmithFW@aol.com I especially wanted to thank you for revealing the identity of the
author of the "From the Cloud of Lester Bangs" notes that bookended Psychotic
Reactions -- I've always been curious about that. Subj: Hope you don't mind me asking Subj: Let It Blurt rocks! From: "Doug Cawker"
From: Joe Bonomo I also want to mention that this summer I am starting work on a book From: PRK888@aol.com
I'm writing regarding your Lester bibliography and your request for info on things you might have missed. After going through it, I was reminded of a piece I'm convinced I saw in one of my Dad's old Playboys which I don't think you mentioned. It was a short piece in the music reviews section about the disco scene in New York, so it was obviously from the late '70s, and seemed not dissimilar from the story you included of Lester's night out at the disco. I wish I still have it for confirmation, since I would hate to send you on a futile search, but my photographic memory is hardly ever wrong. I hope this helps if you're trying to compile a complete list, but I felt compelled to write you anyway just to say a job well done. Hopefully you will be able to read my oral history of Canadian rock from 1985-95 when it is published next year.
Sent: Friday, September 08, 2000 6:53 AM Subject: hats off from Night Rally magazine
dear jim:
you really buried that e mail address on that site. but i found it, and that saved me a phone call to chicago (i like chicago. don't you wish they sold nelson algren action figures on the streets?)
THANK YOU for writing "let it blurt". my father bought me "psychotic reactions and carburetor dung" when i was a teen-- lester was a huge influence on my life and my writing career; i did rock writing as a young woman, and have been publishing fiction for eleven years. now, i am running my own literary magazine, NIGHT RALLY, and our first issue has been well received. we are published out of philadelphia, and while we often try to feature philly artists, we are not "local"; we sponsored a fiction component of the longstanding piccolo spoleto festival in charleston, south carolina this past spring, and we have fiction and prose by the late andy kaufman in our next issue.
to find out more about the magazine in general, go to: http://www.nightrally.org
amber dorko stopper editor in chief night rally magazine
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
From: Daniel Hannon To: jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: Saturday, September 02, 2000 5:21 AM Subject: Lester Bangs
Dear Jim, Just a thank you to say how much I really enjoyed "Let it Blurt". I have a two page article written about a meeting with Lester in 1981 by Jon Langford of the Mekons. It was written to coincide with the re-release of psychotic reactions and carburettor dung in England and was published in Q magazine around winter 1996. I can't be more precise because I don't have the rest of the magazine ( I ripped the article off from the staff copy of the magazine at HMV where I was working at the time). If you are interested in reading it let me know and I will get it scanned and sent to you. Yours sincerely Daniel Hannon.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
From: Bill Tuomala To: jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: Wednesday, August 30, 2000 1:50 AM Subject: thanks
Jim
Lester Bangs has been my favorite writer ever since I got Psychotic Reactions for Christmas back in '87. I remember you saying on your last Sound Opinions show here in the Twin Cities a few years back that you were working on a Lester Bangs bio, and I awaited its publication from that day on.
So I had to write you to say that Let It Blurt is some great work. I plan on reading it again this fall as I blew through it so fast last spring. I already know I'll enjoy it the second time around.
keep up the good work
Bill Tuomala Minneapolis
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
From: "ray hadlock" To: jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: August 27, 2000 7:23:37 PM GMT Subject: 'Extra CREEM'?
Hey Jim--
I'm Clyde Raymond Hadlock & I freelanced stuff to CREEM; I think the 1st stuff appeared in about 1/74-- I had maybe 7 or 8 reviews & a few Rock-a-ramas & a feature between then & I dunno, maybe '76 or '77. Never met Lester face-to-face, but as you can imagine we talked quite a bit on the phone-- his letters are most likely lost. You're getting the short version of all this, since I can still hear Lester screaming "three hundred words, ya fuckin' beatnik!" I would love to see another Lester collection. Can you imagine my elation and then horror when I saw CD in the bookstore only to discover it had been assembled by Greil Marcus? He monkey-fucked it exactly as badly as I knew he would-- in other words about 40% of the stuff included & excluded made perfect sense to him & no one else. I could hose-whip him for leaving out the Bay City Rollers thing from PRM. And so on... Well, there I go-- anyway, I can't imagine you didn't uncover the 'Extra Creem' inserts in the center of issues of CREEM that circulated in Michigan-- surely Jaan or somebody else had some? They might have had a different name even, but they were these stapled-in yellow paper inserts with 'local' coverage-- maybe Lester didn't do anything noteworthy? It seems like I remember a review of a local bar he did: 'The jukebox was broken and it played 'Mississippi Queen' or something equally appropriate all night and nobody noticed...' Well, certainly he woulda written for that section too, & certainly it woulda been noteworthy... Hope somebody has some, if they've been overlooked-- I probably will remember other stuff too, as soon as I send this-- sorry I 'missed' you if you were trying to track me down (& if you were, that's pretty scary). I might have been able to provide a useable story or two-- he still owes me copies of _Raw Power_ for that fucking 8-track of _Metal Machine Music_ I stole from the record store for him-- imagine being polygraphed in a Holiday Inn by a retired police sergeant and telling him 'of course we steal from them-- I'm getting 2.75 an hour-- I stole _Metal Machine Music_ for Lester Bangs, an important American writer, who needed it for research purposes, so that he could monitor the effects it has on pedestrians...' Anyway, as infuriating as he could be, he did more good than harm in my life and I miss him every day-- how many times a week do YOU see/hear something & think "I wish Lester were here to throw down on this...' ? Yep. Well, fuck the 300 words; any bio is a lot like the 3-blind-guys-describing-the-elephant story, and all-in-all I was pretty happy with your book-- I would trust you to assemble another collection of Lester's stuff and get it right and I hope you get the chance. Write if you see fit...
-ray
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Date: 8/27/00 11:42:06 AM Central Daylight Time From: AliBnSkemr To: JimDeRo Sent on: AOL 4.0 for Windows sub 104
Hi Jim--reading your book on Lester and hats off to you--its excellent. A cranky old prog fan like me finds plenty of offense in many of his screeds. But my love of a good slam almost makes me forgive. Which leads to a favor I must ask of you: I have been searching the web for the text of Blood Feast of Reddy Kilowatt! for what seems like forever. Would you be able to help me find a copy (why its not in carbeurator dung i wonder)?
Best to you and yours--and thanks for reveiwing the Halford CD--just bought it and its great!
John
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
From: Steve Crawford To: <jimdero@earthlink.net Date: 8/19/00 9:33:06 PM Subject: Bangs
Jim,
I just read the Lester Bangs book. Great book and undoubtedly it was a labor of love. Hope I'm not annoying you by dropping you a line.
Shameless request: I'm a big Cheap Trick fan and I didn't know Lester ever wrote about them. Do you have the copy of the review he did on the first Cheap Trick album (Stereo Review, Sep 77)? I'd love to see that.
I started reading Creem about 1980 and it became a bible for me. I used to memorize every issue. (I see we might have some similar interests - I've had letters published in Creem and the Wrestling Observer Newsletter!!). John Mendelssohn and I corresponded for many years and he even thanked me in his "I/Caramba" book. (And heck, Richard Riegal even sent me a tape of Lester with Birdland - wotta guy!).
By the way, what is Rick Johnson doing these days? The creativity of his writing just amazed me. (My parents got really worried when I'd start laughing about things like "Geno-type Cointoss" in reference to Freddie Mercury).
Well, since I'm starting to ramble, I'd better sign off again. Thanks again for providing an insight into Lester's life and the rock critic world.
Steve Crawford
P.S. Gee, and do you really think Robert Christgau attacked you so much over the "dinner versus pie" issue or for looking like a pathetic homophobe when it came to Vince Aletti?!?!
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
From: "David Rensin" To: <jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: Sunday, August 20, 2000 1:18 PM Subject: Lester
Jim First, thanks for doing the book. I read it on vacation and, having been a minor L.A. rock writer/critic in the early 70s (I was at the Memphis gathering, among others), it was like a terrific journey through the past chock full of people I knew and have never forgotten. The main thing, of course, is that the book is really really wonderful. Among everything else, you got Lester as a human being; you got his heart -- which couldn't have been easy. A lesser writer would have just gone for the gonzo. You did more. As my long-time buddy (since 1973) Cameron said, "You caught the keys." In my opinion you put them in a really fine car.
Btw: I spent a drunken afternoon with Lester in his hotel room (or mine) in Kingston, Jamaica, on that Bob Marley junket. We drank local rum. Yeah, 'mon. I will never forget sunset in Marley's backyard, him sitting on the BMW, his pals darting in and out of the surrounding journalists, asking us Bible questions.
Also, glad to see you're with Chris Calhoun. He's a pal and a great guy. Just saw him in LA a couple weeks ago.
One question: reading the thank you's -- who is Carrie Anne Svingen? How old is she? I ask because she may be someone I knew, only with a different last name...and I've been looking for her.
congrats again David Rensin
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
'Subject: Lester Leaps In Date: Mon, 31 Jul 2000 09:46:08 GMT From: mark eggins
Jim,
just a short note to say I really enjoyed your Lester bio (picked it up in Tower Records in Tokyo). He was and is a big hero of mine and a big inspiration to my humble critical efforts over the years so it was good to see he got a very fitting bio.
Any chance of you perhaps editing another volume of Lester`s work? Criminal that there is only one available thus far!
Regards
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: Let it Blurt Date: 5 Aug 00 13:31:03 MST From: Mike Long
Jim:
Great book (Read review in Denver's Westword, ordered online). Lester's kept me from a life of listening to the Marshall Tucker and Pink Floyd. I discovered Creem too late (about '74) to read most of Lester's work, but enjoyed reading Psychotic Reactions... and the Blondie book. Hopefully your book will encourafe someone to release more of Lester's writings. Again, thanks for your great book. Where can I read your reviews?
- Good luck, Mike
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: patti smith Date: Wed, 2 Aug 2000 15:24:45 -0700 From: Paul Gilvary
I just finished your Let it Blurp book. I loved it!
I did find one mistake though. You attribute Patti's quote This is the era where everybody creates to her Horses album. That was from her Wave album when she was redoing the Byrds' So You Want To Be A RocknRoll Star.
I'm a Patti fanatic. Like I said though, your book was great.
Paul Gilvary
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Let it Blurt Date: 7/22/00 9:18:06 PM Central Daylight Time From: (Ron Dulin) To: jimdero@aol.com
Mr. DeRogatis-
I just finished reading Let it Blurt, and it left with me with a strange sort of melancholy. Fine work, though I'm sure I'm not the first to say it.
My question: With so much of Bangs' work left uncollected, why has there been no follow-up to Psychotic Reactions&c? Reading excerpts from his works in your bio only made me want to read them in their entirety.
Best,
Ron Dulin
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: <BLet it Blurt!</B Date: 7/23/00 11:15:31 AM Central Daylight Time From: Artknarf To: JimDeRo Sent on: AOL 5.0 for Windows sub 105
Jim, Wow what can I say but, a perfect book! It is really enjoyable to read such a well researched and organized book. There was just the right amount about all parts of Lester's life. I found the early years in his life surprising and interesting. The story unfolds very nicely w/out a lot of empty speculation or the sort of tabloid Told here for the very first time! crap. A well rounded picture of Lester is presented in the book, you did the job proud! I also found the information on the birth of rock criticism, and the other writers enlightening. Now I am going to look for the Tosches book. The beginnings of Creem when they moved to Walled Lake was unbelievable! It's hard to imagine that sort of setup happening today. Living and working together in one house, which would be fun from about age twenty to twenty-two, reminds me of some the houses I lived in during college. Maybe it was the way the pay was at that time, but it seemed like the writers were paid exceedingly small sums, and practically a company town/house sort of setup were its pretty difficult for the workers to move up or out. As you said Lester freelanced more than anyone else there.
I think it shows his energy, and as pointed to in other parts, how he always got up from his low points and found ways of productivity. Lester's big heart comes through in the book, as do the clownish aspects of his personality. His drinking and outlandish stuff was rightfully covered, but without making him seem like a boorish hack. He may have had a sharp tongue at times, and all advanced drinkers can be assholes at times, but I felt from the book that Lester was a sensitive being and kind to others. He definitely didn't come off as a Jim Morrison type, who although, wrote some good songs (I like the Doors second album best of their work as an album) he always seemed to me from what I have read to be a very charismatic sociopath whom believed his own lies and enjoyed hurting people. As far as the ending I didn't think it was depressing. It was sad of course that he dies suddenly, but he lived his life and did a lot for dying so young. I disagree with some of his friends that couldn't see him doing anything different. I think just before he died he was in a sort of getting his mind ready to move. Who knows what would have happened? My feeling is he would have left NY and wrote about music but probably other topics as well.
His death reads as accidental to me. It doesn't take much when the wrong medication is taken together. A close friend of mine almost died from a similar scenario. My friend takes anti-anxiety medicine, and one night she was sick with headache and diarrhea. She took some anti-diarrhea medicine and something for her headache and the combination of the three almost killed her!
It was interesting to read the criticism of Psychotic Reactions and Carburetor Dung. When that book came out I very excitedly ran out and bought it. I thought it was good, but was also disappointed. As someone whom had read Some but by no means even half of Lester's work, I thought the selected pieces left out a lot of the joy, and some of the better pieces that I had read. Thanks for putting" How to Be a Rock Critic" in your book. Regarding the Greil Marcus choices, well I have usually found his work interesting but unconvincing. His books often have some agenda that I find as hype and slanted as anything. He definitely has been guilty of omission to strengthen his viewpoint. And he reads way too much into a pop song. Anyway when I gave that book to friends to read, who had never read Lester; they loved it, and I couldn't figure out my disappointment until now. Anyway I feel you have corrected the bad job done by Marcus, and wrote a great book that does justice to Lester and should be of interest to anyone whom reads, even if they have no interest in rock-and-roll. I could really go on and on! But will say thanks for keeping the humor in the book. In my aesthetic all work should have moments of humor, besides Lester was a pretty funny cat, and it would be horrible to have missed that. The end with the cop asking for the rare record album as Lester is laying there being dead on the sofa is incredible, pure Monty Python or pure Bangs, terrific!!!
Thanks again for a great book.
Frank Taylor
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: your excellent book Date: Thu, 21 Sep 2000 12:52:05 -0400 From: Robert Press JIM:
I just got done reading LET IT BLURT. fantastic. you really told me a lot of what i wanted to know. i never could get enough lester, and still can't. i remember riding around in an MG one gloriously aimless new jersey afternoon in 1980, being driven around new brunswick by a hairdresser named sinful (maybe you've run into her) and finding a trashed rock magazine underfoot in which i came across one of lester's histories of punk rock. i already knew who he was and that what he wrote was worth reading. i remember cracking up as i read sinful the article out loud -- something like "and when you've been up for a week on romilar and you're staring at your best friend whose face is collapsing in slow motion and he says to you 'i think i forgot how to think,' the last thing in the world you want to hear is suite judy blue eyes."
there's no getting around the impact of those spontaneous timely discoveries -- i guess it's like listening to sergeant pepper in the summer of '67 as opposed to 30 years later -- but i had to drool over your bibliography of lester's articles. as much as i enjoyed PSYCHEDELIC REACTIONS, i agree with you that it was heavily weighted to one side of lester's writings. what i always enjoyed best were the almost throw-away reviews -- funniest things i ever read. how can i find some of those articles? any internet goldmine sources?
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: I Knew Lester When We Were Kids
Hello, Jim-- I just left you a voicemail message at the Sun Times, and am writing as well to tell you that I knew Lester Bangs when he was thirteen and fourteen. I was two years and three grades ahead of him at El Cajon Valley High School, and we lost touch after I graduated. But I know when and why he changed his name to Lester, and still have a number of wonderful letters and poems that he wrote to me.
Just to entice you, these early writings include Lester's version of the song "Billy Boy," which, in part, went something like this: . . . Yes I am a witless Witness, humble, meek, and shitless. He's a young man and cannot leave his mother.
I'll be glad to share these treasures with you, for a future expanded edition of the bio or simply for your own delight and further understanding of Lester.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Fw: overdue congrats From: "Steve Simels" Sent: Wednesday, September 13, 2000 1:56 PM Jim -- just found your homepage and e-mail (I
had tried to find you through the paper with no success). Anyway, I just wanted to tell
you that "Let It Blurt" is really great. I knew Lester professionally (I
actually auditioned for his band with Nancy) and you nailed both him and the scene
exactly. A first-rate job.....
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
From: Jeffrey Morgan
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: lester Date: Thu, 19 Oct 2000 09:23:17 -0700 From: Dave Perry To: jimdero@earthlink.net
Jim:
Just finished Let it Blurt. For the second time. I hope you don't mind me using this address to send the following:
What a great book. For the past 14 years, I've been the staff music writer for The Lowell Sun in Lowell, MA, the birthplace/resting place of Jack Kerouac. So in some vague way I know this game, though all the rules and most of the possibilities have changed since Lester wrote. Yeah, I get my 20 minutes on the phone with some band when they blow through town, and I write my advance, and I cover the show. And then, unless it's that singular, extraordinary event, it's gone. For years, I've heard the resounding chorus of Kerouac in Lester Bangs' writing. I wrote the liners for Rhino's Kerouac box set a few years back, and one of my jobs was to connect Jack, as an influence, to the a long line of pop musicians. So why didn't I mention Lester? I'm still kicking myself. I am 43. Like you, I suppose, but a few years older, I was one of those kids who sopped up Lester's writing in my room, surrounded by records. Back when I was writing about music for free while I got paid to cover, well, everything, for a weekly paper in Connecticut (early 80s) I used to write for this freebie rag called Vox Pop. I heard at one point that Lester was accessible in New York, but never planned the trip that you did, never caught those keys. Reading Let It Blurt made me wish I had. Your job of reporting was extraordinary, and what I loved best was the way you set Lester apart from those he often worked with. He was indeed worlds apart, and it had nothing to do with drugs or filth or body odor.
The "Dean" and his ilk always forgot how to draw me in, or never cared to. The scene of Christgau and his wife over dinner at Lester's broke my heart. And having seen Almost Famous, with its conscience wandering around an apartment crammed with records (yeah, I noticed which ones were visible, too--Crowe got it right) in a "Detroit Sucks" t-shirt, made me re-read Let It Blurt. It's funny the way Lester Bangs has come back not to haunt us but to remind us of some things that are all but forgotten. Kerouac, I can tell you, came back similarly. Oddly, I didn't call the publisher for a review copy when your book was published. I wanted to spend my own cash on this one. And I can't tell you how glad I am that I did. So, I guess, thanks. I always knew there was indeed a man in there. You finally introduced me to him. Thanks for the keys.
Dave Perry The Lowell Sun 15 Keaqrney Square Lowell, MA 01853
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: Lester Bangs Date: Fri, 13 Oct 2000 18:22:18 -0500 From: LDC To: jimdero@earthlink.net
On my drive back to work after lunch I was listening to "Fresh Air" on the radio.. Usually, I find it delightful but not on this afternoon.. I am sure you are familiar with the show since you were the featured guest. The topic was your book " Let it Blurt - The Life & Times of Lester Bangs, America's Greatest Rock Critic.
I always find it hard to believe that someone with second hand knowledge is always able to form such a concrete opinion about Jehovah Witnesses. I can tell you have never talked with a JW. Mr. Bangs opinions, even though he was raised as a JW, were highly distorted. JW's enjoy music just as much as the next person. My uncle is a JW, and he owns a oldies vinyl record store on the strip in Hollywood.
To be one of Jehovah's Witnesses he would have had to give up the destructive life style that killed him. When someone becomes so self invented, emotionally and physically in what they are doing, little else matters to them. That person, especially if gifted with words and pen can be ruinous to someone else's reality.
I did not know him personally, the way you did, but I do have friends that are heavy drug users and I can tell you this, the only opinions they trust about life are their own. I just hope that next time you decide to describe a group of people to the world, the least you can do is interview someone from that group. By the way Coltrane's " My Favorite Things" is a classic.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Good Book. Date: Tue, 10 Oct 2000 10:40:42 -0400 From: "Joe Bronowich" To: jimdero@earthlink.net
Mr. DeRogatis:
As a fellow Hudson County native (West New York) I wanted to tell you how much I enjoyed "Let It Blurt". Your compassionate, well researched study was informative and entertaining. As insightful as the book was, Mr. Bangs still remains an enigma - a classic case of "Trust the art, not the artist". I wonder along with you what might have come had he been able to get at that novel. Despite what others may say, your subtitle is correct: he clearly was Americas Greatest Rock Critic.
Do you think he'd still be writing about music today?
I could bore you with may more paragraphs about how "Creem" was my bible, yada yada yada, but I'm sure your have better things to do with your time. Thanks for the book, I look forward to the next one.
Regards,
Joe Bronowich
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: <B Hullo</B Date: 10/11/00 12:57:47 AM Central Daylight Time From: dmahoney To: JimDero@aol.com ('JimDero@aol.com')
Jim,
I just spent the past few hours devouring every word of yours that I could find on Ironminds.com. I was particularly impressed with how lucid, yet sharp, accurate and entirely alternative the pieces are, even as I wondered: If all of the mainstream megahits are polluted by predictable appeals to the least-common-denominator, most-numerous-buck, is there anything in music today that you like? Wanting more, I also checked out some of your equivalent Sun-Times pieces, on Pearl Jam and the Pumpkins, and was surprised--though I shouldn't have been--at how you lined your gloves with velvet, softening the edge of some of the punches for the wider audience.
My interest is more than casual--I just finished a 2.5 year run writing a 700-word music column in our local alt Boise Weekly, sharpening my prose as I honed my views, but ultimately feeling myself begin to burn down under the inevitable cynicism that arises from writing of dull, bloated national acts and nascent, sometimes very derivative or simply bad local acts. Boise is still best known for Doug Martsch, Curtis Stigers and maybe Caustic Resin, with little else national-caliber of any genre on the horizon. Usually, the too-kind non-confrontation geek in me would pull back the hardest blows on the local bands--not wanting to judge them at a ridiculously high national standard, and disdaining the cliched rock critic hack attacks--but I always felt weak and emasculated in doing so. I don't particularly regret that stance, since I believe that natural selection should weed out these bands unaided by some snot-nosed critic, but incriminating bands with faint praise at the margins grew tiresome. The world of good, honest, accurate but fair rock criticism, written in a voice of one's own, still has great appeal to me, though.
BTW, I picked up a copy of your Bangs book and breezed through it easily and enjoyably, which is a high compliment in this too-hectic day of constant distraction. It was nice to know of Bangs as an erratic, unpredictable Meathead, not merely part of an alliterative toss-off line in a rem song. Your account of your interview with Lester was particularly riveting. Do you agree with Greil that the best writer of his generation wrote record reviews? I'm decidedly undecided (and skeptical) on that one.
Best regards,
--Dale Mahoney
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Hello from J Church.. Date: 10/6/00 12:59:51 PM Central Daylight Time To: jimdero@aol.com
Hello,
I'm not really sure if this is still your e-mail address, so I'll keep this short.
My name is Lance Hahn and I'm in a band called J Church. We're sort of an indie-emo(blech)-type-punk-pop-band thing. It's no big deal, but I wanted to send you a couple of our CDs to check out. I really liked "Let It Blurt" a lot. It's funny, because when you get right down to it, it's the same old story. There's always the originator of any art form and a million copy cats all missing the point.
Anyway, I've also been a writer for Maximum Rock-N-Roll since 1983. I still write for them, but am attempting to get printed elsewhere. I'd love to send you a copy of my newsletter to see what you think. A lot of it is just ranting and raving. It's only half about music. The most popular thing I've written so far is a comparison of Star Wars to Game 5 of the '75 World Series.
So send me your mailing address if you could and I'll send you a bunch of stuff.
Thanx, Lance J Church
"Artists care about aesthetics as much as birds care about ornithology" - Barnett Newman
"One Mississippi" - J Church Brand new double LP on Honest Don's Strictly Analog Recordings...
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Thank You Date: 10/3/00 5:31:14 PM Central Daylight Time From: nhlcritic To: JimDero@aol.com
Mr. DeRogatis:
I just returned from Stockholm, Sweden where I devoured your book, LET IT BLURT. I want to thank you for writing such a thoughtful, comprehensive book on the life of Lester Bangs.
I grew up in Brooklyn listening to classic rock, punk and new wave. I remember my friends checking out copies of Creem and talking about Bangs but I was painfully unaware of his work in the world of Rock criticism. But I loved- and hated- the music of that time.
I felt as though I was living through that period observing Bangs as he moved through the years searching for something new to say or just commenting on the state of music at the time. Equal parts sad and comedic, LET IT BLURT made sense of the often dense movement dominated, in my opinion, by unreadable critics whose prose was often more confusing than enlightening.
As a writer I found your book a wonderful guide in the art of writing a biography. I shall certainly read it again. So thank you for the inspiration.
I also caught the fact that you write about wrestling which is something that I am also very interested. Geez my pay-per-view bill reflects that near fanaticism every month!
A funny aside: I grew up in Brooklyn at the same time as Peter Senercha, a.k.a Tazz. He was friends with a few of my buddies who went to Franklin K. Lane High School.
I look forward to reading more from you in the future.
With best wishes,
John Sanful
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
To: <jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: Tuesday, September 26, 2000 6:21 PM Subject: Bangs book
As a former NYC freelancer/lightweight rock critic of that glorious era, I'd like to say how much I totally appreciated the book - but I can't. The nostalgic phlegm conjured up in your tome was completely thwarted by learning that poor Lester died whilst listening to that wretched Brit synth-pop-pablum, DARE by The Human League. Not that it surprised me mind you, it just reminds me of how cruel God is. Lester clearly heard that and realized there was no place left for a true r&r fan. Sadly, he was right, although a part of me likes to think that he might've embraced, even cheered, for say, Eminem, who for some reason feels more like someone who today comes closest to exuding true punk spirit than nearly all of his rap/psuedo-punk counterparts combined.
By the way, I passed the book along to my friend Matt, who roadied for The Ramones during their 10 headiest years and he returned it last week offering me no review other than a head-shake, which I think kind of sums it all up.
It was a good summer read. Now I can stash it in the closet with my other memories of the time: dusty vinyl that I occasionally pull out and crusted-over, half-used bottles of Crazy Color. That shit doesn't even cover gray.
Best Regards,
Jacquie Tellalian/nyc
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
To: <jimdero@earthlink.net Sent: Tuesday, September 26, 2000 5:43 PM Subject: Let It Blurt
Dear Jim,
I really enjoyed Let It Blurt, which I just read on holiday in southern Italy -- a very incongruous setting! I'm very interested in tracking down a copy of the novel "Harry Vernon At Prep". I've tried all the usual place -- Amazon, the Strand in New York etc. I don't think it was ever in print here in the UK, let alone out of print. Any ideas as to where I could get hold of a copy would be welcome.
Well done on the book.
Best wishes, Andrew Bendel
Subject: Let it Blurt Date: Thu, 28 Dec 2000 07:18:53 -0800 From: "George Kopp" Hi Jim, I grew up in Birmingham. Even had pizza at Pasquale's. Saw the movie "Almost Famous" and the the character Phillip Seymour Hoffman played, Lester Bangs. I read Creem magazine, but wasn't as say a devout Lester follower. Looking back on it I read the reviews superfically. If it sounded good on the radio I bought the album. On a whim my wife bought your book for me for Christmas. I must say I really enjoyed your book. Regards, George Kopp P.S. If you are going to do "time" in Detroit. Birmingham isn't a bad place to do it.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: thanks * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: i'm almost finished with _let it blurt_!
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: More
omissions.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: lester
bangs bibliography omission
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: [Fwd:
Black47eNews]
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject:
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: America's
Greatest Rock Critic
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: FWD: Hi
Jim
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Subject: LIB etc. Date: Wed, 27 Dec 2000 20:26:58 From: "michael layne-heath" Hello again Jim: Well, after months of browsing thru copies
at every available opportunity in local * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: fan mail (I guess)
Subj: Let it Blurt * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Lester Bangs bio * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Let it Blurt * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: fan * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject:
...and I wanted to let you know that I think
you're a fantastic writer and interviewer. I read "Let it Blurt" a few months
ago and thought it was easily one of the best, most interesting, and most entertaining
biographies I've ever read. Lester Bangs is one of my heroes (I'm looking into actually
getting a Lester tattoo, believe it or not) and I really think that you did him tremendous
justice. By the way, what did you think of Phillip Seymour Hoffman's portrayal of Bangs in
"Almost Famous?" Seeing as how I've never seen video of Bangs or anything, I
couldn't really judge, but it still seemed kind of off to me. I dunno, maybe it was just
the movie (I was very excited to see it only to be very disappointed by it's lack of rock
'n' rollness). * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: bangs book dear Jim DeRogatis, * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: Thanks for "Let It Blurt" * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Hi Jim- * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: Les Bangs Just wanted to say that I am half way through
LET IT Regards- Jess Montgomery Hey Jim, I'm Jason from the Nasty On. we're happy you like our song. Really liked your book on Lester, I'm currently searching for your "Kaleidescope Eyes" book. We sent a copy of our EP to "Revolver" as well. Our website setting-up has taken some time, but it should be up soon. Do you know anywhere I can get a copy of Lester Bangs & The Delinquents album? I have the Birdland record and were covering "Kill Him Again" soon. Seeya Jason
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: a personal note, jim * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: jim * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: A few words of dissent Pretty shallow, Jim. I like to imagine that
there was always an unmistakble layer of self-mockery about the raging egotism; at the
time, there probably weren't four people on the face of the earth with lower self-esteem.
Pretty obtuse too, I must say, suggesting that there's something unusual about egotism and
neurosis coinciding. Indeed. 23 years later and with tongue
obviously in cheek, recycling Bud Scoppa's description of me, by which I was greatly
amused. Subj: Let it Blurt * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject: Let It Blurt * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Date: Fri, 22 Jun 2001 08:42:19 -0700 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subj: lester
Subject:
Yet More Praise For Let It Blurt With
regards to " Let It Blurt ", it certainly served as inspiration for any aspiring
music journalists; although I was dismayed at the suggestions somewhere that Lester's
musings would not be Regards, * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject:
Thanks for Let It Blurt * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject:
Let it blurt * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Subject:
fan letter Jim, Back to Contents |